Hey guys, I released a montage today and would like to get some feedback; you can view the video here:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSnMNL6tsx0

The montage isn't really clled 'unique' but I just thought I'd put that in the thread title as it's an theme I tried to uphold in the actual 'tage. The video is pretty creative with a few new ideas and a super-clean edit.

Please let me know what you think guys

i liked it. it had a very good flow. I have mixed feelings about the choice of not using game sounds. On one hand, i like the sound of the sniper shots, or the medals being said. BUT i also kinda liked hpow none of that was present,cause it made it have a unique flow. kinda like only the music and clips is what you get. Personally, i think it would have been cooler with minimal game effects. Kinda like a enhanced sniper shot, or only the overkill being said, with some cool sound effects on the overkill. great vid none the less, i watched all of it, soemthing i cant say i do for over 50% of montages

Haha i'll be honest, I absolutely hated the music. But as far as the editing and gameplay I was pretty entertained. The editing really was pretty smooth and I loved the color fades. You got mad potential man.

Yeah the choise of not using the in game sounds was raised by someone on the comments as well, it may have been better, like mentioned, to have just included key sounds, like shots or high medals. However I'm still very happy with the feedback so far, and I'm glad I can bring something different to the table

BTW, JAW DROP at the first stick...i thought i had a good mlg stick on the Pit, but sheesh... Yours is disgusting!!!

{youtube}zSnMNL6tsx0{/youtube}

I watched it 7 times just for the song. I loved it! So fucking amazing.

There was a bit too much Twixtor, lol you overused it a tad bit. At the start of the vid and at 1:22, I didn't really like how you cut through the clip, it ruined the smooth and sluggish feel the vidoe was devoloping. Some nice masks and transitions. I really liked the CC and the blur, it fit nicely. The grid shouldn't be there, it didn't look good at all.

Gameplay was disgusting, expecially the killtrocity in Fundry, r whatever and that triple on Guardian. IMO, it would've sounded better with audio. I like hearing the gunshots and the atmosphere of the game in a montage.

Anyways, I faved it and hopefully, you'll come out with something longer next time.

EDIT: That's what she said. lol ^^^^^^^^^^rofl

- Fatal

Sick nasty tage, i agree with fatal bout that red grid on valhalla just looked kinda dumb but everything else in my opinions was beast. I personally love the twixtor slow mo haha looks so epic. Keep on makin vids bro, you for sure have potential to be great editor. If this tage had some separate pan angles and maybe some color corrections it woulda been perfect for me.

wow guys thankyou so much for the great feedback! Yeah the grid was a 50/50 that doesn't seem to have worked out, but whatever; and I agree about having mroe angles, unfortuantly though my capper didn't really cap many good ones but overall I'm really glad you all like it, and that there are different opinions on the music and stuff, I like a good bit of controversy! haha

I dont think the music was bad. BUT i think it works for more of an intro song, not to be used throughout the WHOLE montage.